Cash Bonuses

Updated: June 04, 2009

"A bonus is an addition to regular salary or compensation that is provided, usually near year end, to enable employees to share in profits resulting from a successful year" (Leimberg and McFadden, p. 309). The above is the opening dialogue provided for in the textbook used in a graduate-level course. A second source defines bonus as "a pay plan that rewards employees for recent performance rather than historical performance" (Robbins and Judge, p. 231). In recent years, the pendulum has been swinging in the direction of paying heavy bonuses, and relying on this aspect of variable compensation. Recent media, including all of the articles on AIG, has drawn considerable attention to this aspect of Wall Street compensation. The purpose of this paper is to define bonus plans, discuss when they are used, and to determine the advantages, disadvantages, and tax implications of cash bonus plans.

"For many jobs, annual bonuses are a significant component of the total compensation. Among Fortune 100 CEOs, the bonus (with a mean of $1.01 million) generally exceeds the base salary (with a mean of $863,000). Increasingly, bonus plans are casting a larger net within organizations to include lower-ranking employees. Many companies now routinely reward production employees with bonuses in the thousands of dollars when company profits improve" (Robbins and Judge, p. 230 and 231). As noted above, cash bonuses are very prevalent. It is also difficult to pick up any financial newspaper these days without reading about this aspect of compensation. Cash bonuses are used as a form of variable compensation that is usually paid in a lump sum and tied to performance, profit, or other goals specified by the employer. Bonuses can be used for individuals, and they can also be used for groups and teams. "Organizations may establish variable pay plans for teams or groups to improve productivity, tie pay to team performance, improve customer service or production quality, and increase employee retention" (Mathis and Jackson, p. 399). There are different triggers for payment of a cash bonus. Some possibilities include the time of year for retention purposes, increased sales, successful teamwork, improvements in safety or attendance, and the list could be more extensive depending on the company. Some companies use bonuses for executives as an incentive and others use spot bonuses, a bonus paid on the spot to reward good performance. A discussion of how bonuses can be used would not be complete without discussing pay for performance and pay-performance relationships. "There can be a direct incentive effect on those who are currently employed by the organization, with different pay systems influencing both the amount of money that can be attained as well as the estimated likelihood of its attainment. These characteristics, in turn, are believed to influence how hard, smart, and persistently people work toward obtaining such rewards" (Gerhart and Rynes, p. 119). "The notion of a relationship between pay practices and characteristics of applicants and employees has been extended to the case of pay basis, or how one pays" (Gerhart and Rynes, p. 119). If one performs well and is compensated each time they perform well with a bonus, one might conclude that their performance is likely to result in compensation and may be motivated to this compensation. The cash bonus is a simple tool that can be used for this type of motivation.

After the discussion above about advantages, it is only fitting to also engage in a discussion of the disadvantages of bonuses. Most of the disadvantages are tax-related. In general, bonuses fail to offer the opportunity for the employee to defer taxation of compensation for more than one year, and they are taxable to the employee as ordinary income (Leimberg and McFadden, p. 309). The tax deferral rules are especially true due to a section of IRS code called 409A, which was added within the last decade. Companies may pay bonuses that are significant either because of a good year or in some cases for retention purposes, as we are especially aware today given the situation with AIG and other similar companies. If the bonuses are considered "reasonable", there could be justifications for deductions. "Reasonableness of compensation is often tested in accordance with circumstances existing when the bonus agreement is entered into rather than when the bonus is actually paid." (Leimberg and McFadden, p. 309).


Reference List

Gerhart, B. and Rynes, S.L. (2003). Compensation, Thousand Islands, CA: Sage Publications, Inc.

Leimberg, S.R. & McFadden, J.J.(2007). Employment Benefit And Retirement Planning, Tenth Edition, Cincinnati, OH: The National Underwriter Company

Mathis, R.L. & Jackson, J.H. (2006). Human Resources Management, Eleventh Edition, Mason, OH: Thomson

Reilly, P. & Brown, D. (2008, 4Q). Employee Engagement: What Is the Relationship With Reward Management; WorldatWork Journal, p. 37-47

Robbins S.P.& Judge, T.A. (2009). Organizational Behavior, Thirteenth Edition, Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson, Prentice Hall

Featured Research
  • Business Meeting Showdown

    It is no secret that communication and collaboration are at the heart of success and longevity for any business. However, as businesses become more global and more employees work remotely, video conferencing is being increasingly used as an alternative to face-to-face interactions. There are pros to both business travel and video conferencing such as personal connection and ease of use. However, there are cons as well ranging from travel delays to being technologically reliant. more

  • Mobile Communication Showdown

    It's no secret that businesses are becoming agiler and employees are spending more time away from their desks. The question isn't should we get rid of our landlines, but how quickly can we replace them?However, staying connected with your colleagues, clients, and customers is absolutely essential for cultivating long-term, lucrative relationships that will help your company achieve success. more

  • Signs you are Ready for Mobile BI

    With workforces moving more and more mobile on a daily basis, it is essential to ensure that your company is able to arm your employees with the analytics that they need to succeed. 89% of business leaders believe that Big Data will revolutionize business operations in the same way that the internet did. These numbers show the trend towards investing in a BI system. more

  • 15 Ways to Optimize Your Contact Center

    We live in a time where customer experience is seen as an important competitive differentiator. Given this, wouldn't you like to make sure that your contact center is fully optimized to meet your business needs? Deciding to upgrade and optimize your contact center is a big step, and one that shouldn't be done without due diligence and plenty of research. more

  • Stress-Free Video Conferencing

    It should shock no one that video conferencing technology is an amazing tool to connect and engage with business contacts in a more personal and effective way. In fact, only 7% of how we communicate is through words, whereas a whopping 93% is through tone of voice and body language. To further the strength of video conferencing, 99% of professionals feel that by improving communication and collaboration, productivity will be positively impacted. more