Need Help Keeping "A" Players During Tough Times?

Updated: March 25, 2011

The Challenge for HR

Cost restraints will challenge human resources to provide the necessary human capital strategies, but a coherent and focused human capital strategy can address retention. In a Personnel Decisions International (PDI) study conducted in December 2008 and January 2009, executives ranked financial pressure to cut costs and rapid market decline as their top two challenges. Six months earlier, retention was the No. 1 priority. A Watson Wyatt Worldwide survey of 248 companies conducted in October 2008 showed that one in four companies planned to lay off and freeze hiring in 2009.

Important Strategy Elements

Manager Behavior

The prime reason for employees leaving is either their manager or their compensation. The quality of the supervision an employee receives is critical to retention, points out Susan Heathfield, an HR expert. "People leave managers and supervisors more often than they leave companies or jobs," she said.

A good manager knows that the quality of supervision ranks with competitive benefits and compensation as key factors in employee retention. Managers must be well trained, show respect for their employees and be superior communicators. An employee's relationship with his/her manager is the strongest of all engagement drivers, according to a 2006 Conference Board study.

Managers must treat their employees as they would treat their clients: with respect, warmth, politeness and consideration. After all, they help to keep the company's clients.

During tough times, the type of manager required to build a cohesive team is someone who:

  1. Utilizes employees' skills, thereby making them more productive
  2. Practices "management by walking around" (MBWA)
  3. Communicates extensively and daily with employees
  4. Helps to grow and develop team members.

Couple those practices with respect for the employees and you have a manager who is building employee loyalty — a rare commodity today.


The second most frequently talked about retention element is compensation. During difficult times, a positive strategy is required and involves ensuring a competitive pay structure where top performers are properly compensated and mechanisms are in place to retain critical players.

To ensure a competitive pay structure, management must benchmark salary and wage levels against competition, especially where there are numerous employers in the area that could poach a company's talent. And it's critical that management communicates to employees that the company's compensation is comparable to industry competitors.

Because "A" players are always in demand by competitors, especially during financially tough times, it is most important to have a mechanism in place that will retain them. One such device is a retention bonus. Given the many ways such a bonus can be structured, it is imperative that a policy be adopted by human resources regarding its payment — that it will either be paid over time, for example six months, or in a lump sum at the end of designated number of weeks.

During tough times, a comprehensive and effective compensation strategy must cover the retention of mission-critical players. Such employees may be IT gurus, operations wizards, or world-class customer service representatives. Management must determine which skills are currently critical to the stability of business as well as those skills most needed as the business emerges from difficult times.

According to the 2006 Culpepper Pay Trends Survey, many organizations pay such employees a "skill bonus." In effect, it is a lump-sum payment for their expertise. The study found that 54 percent of employers annually review what those critical skills are.


Human resources needs to create a recognition program that says, "Thank you, the company recognizes and appreciates your efforts." But during difficult times, management may push back at spending money on such a program and ask why it is needed.

The rationale again addresses retention:

  1. The program only rewards those that "go above and beyond"— those employees who are "keepers."
  2. A survey by found that 34.2 percent of current and former employees feel there is "insufficient recognition or appreciation of their work, talents, and capabilities" and give that lack as the reason for leaving their jobs.
  3. A recognition program does not have to cost much. Many such programs use certificates of appreciation signed by the executive in charge of that function, a personal note to the employee from the manager or someone more senior, or even $5 gift certificates to fast food establishments.
  4. The cost of such a program is insignificant compared to the cost of turnover, especially of key team members.

Peer teaching can be included in a recognition program. This may present an opportunity to teach the award winner new skills thereby increasing that worker's value to the organization or preparing that person for future movement within the organization.

For the company to get the most value out of a recognition program, regular and public communication of awards is critical. An example of such communication could be creating an "Announcement" section on the company Web site where winners would be congratulated or giving the certificate to the employee in a Town Hall meeting. Public recognition costs very little when compared to the goodwill, morale boosts and cultural reinforcement gained.

One caveat is warranted here. A recognition program can be world class and still be sending a conflicting message. If a company recognizes its star performers, then it must eliminate its bottom performers, especially in tough times. The company cannot afford to keep such employees, and it sends the wrong message to the workforce. Human resources must make sure that its performance management system is working prior to announcing the reward and recognition program.


Training is not only a major driver of employee engagement, but it is critical to success during times of downsizing. In tough times, businesses want employees fully engaged, especially as they reduce staff. Training is one way to ensure full engagement. A 2007 Towers Perrin global study on engagement found that 83 percent of employees "look for opportunities to develop new knowledge or skills" and 84 percent "enjoy challenging work that will allow me to learn new skills."

Every staff member needs to have a personal development plan. The plan addresses critical gaps in skills, knowledge or experience and should be the result of a meeting between employee and manager. Follow-up meetings need to be held at regular intervals, such as monthly, to review progress with any revisions being integrated at that time.

As one training tool, job rotation works well to get employees cross-trained on critical processes, prepared for promotion, or ready to take on more and different responsibilities. Use of this technique requires operations to work with human resources to ensure success and compliance with company policy and any applicable laws or regulations.

In addition, senior management must ensure managers are held accountable for employees' development. This action helps to build a culture of interdependence and teamwork, a necessity during lean times.

Work-life Balance

According to a Coopers & Lybrand survey, Generation Xers aren't impressed with money but rather a balanced lifestyle. Increasingly, employees want flexibility in their jobs and will remain with an employer who guarantees it. In tough times this is especially critical.

For example, the message to call center management is: staff adequately to minimize overtime, which reduces impact on employees' work-life balance and avoids wearing employees out; and acknowledge non-work priorities, such as taking a family member to the doctor.

It has been found that employees become loyal to companies that practice this rule because it shows respect for them as individuals, not just employees.

Organizational Changes

During such economic upheaval, it is important that the organization as a whole envisions those enterprise-wide changes necessary to survive. A few of those changes include:

  1. Flattening the chains of command
  2. Training for front-line managers
  3. Improving internal communications, which are critical in labor-intensive industries such as call centers and shared-service operations.

Management must change how it thinks of employees, viewing them as assets not expenses. This impacts retention, loyalty, and engagement as well as customer service levels. This radical change in management's approach results in asking different questions of employees and different actions. For example, instead of saying, "We'll implement mandatory overtime to cover backlog," management would ask, "Are we acting with disregard in implementing mandatory overtime because it could burn out our people (assets) and hurt retention and customer service metrics?"


In order for human resources to show the value of all the actions taken to address the difficult times, metrics must be set, especially those showing incremental revenue saved or customer service levels achieved. For management, the metrics should include percentage of employees on track with personal development plan completion, and other training metrics. Given the ongoing organizational changes, project timelines and milestones need to be tracked as does each manager's progress with communications.

The most important part of metrics is aggressively reporting them to management and employees. Weekly forums should be scheduled where employees are not only informed about progress, but are allowed to ask questions, and provide input regarding any necessary changes. Given the change in how management looks at its employees, their input is critical and must be a welcomed part of the process.

Featured Research
  • The New SMB Phone Systems Comparison Guide

    Does your small or medium-size business need a new phone system? Then you're in luck! Our new, updated comparison guide helps you cut through superfluous information and narrow down your list of solution providers. Get the latest data on phone system features, pricing, and performance metrics in an easy-to-use format. more

  • Contact Center Software on a Budget

    Although contact center software is necessary for a modern contact center, it can be outrageously expensive. Many companies find that their budget bloats during the implementation process. more

  • How UC Can Help Your Business Survive the Holidays

    The holiday season is filled with frenzy and excitement for businesses and consumers alike. Consumers prepare gift lists, compare brands and prices, and begin shopping with a vigor that is not present most other times of the year. For many businesses, the holiday season accounts for a large profit bump at the end of each year, and companies strive to exceed their goals and keep customers happy during this rush late in the year. more

  • [Infographic] Switching Phone Systems

    There are a lot of possible reasons you might want to switch to a new phone system. The old one might cost too much or be too troublesome to operate and maintain. It might not be flexible enough. It might not be reliable enough. Or it just might not have the kinds of features and capabilities that you need in today’s competitive business climate. more

  • Business Intelligence Software Cost Guide

    Your choice in a BI (Business Intelligence) provider can lead you to make better, data-driven decisions for your business, resulting in significant ROI. Or it can cost hundreds of thousands of dollars with mixed results. more