PBX vs. VoIP

A Description and Overview of the Pros and Cons of VoIP vs. PBX

By Kevin Stewart
Updated: February 07, 2011

Telecommunications needs are as varied as businesses are, and choosing the right features at the right price may seem like a daunting task. A small business looking for a solution to host multiple incoming, outgoing and interoffice calls first has to choose between a traditional Private Branch Exchange, or PBX, and VoIP technology.

Here we present an overview of the pros and cons between these two choices.

 

PBX

The acronym PBX stands for Private Branch eXchange. In legacy telephone systems, the term PBX was used to distinguish private business systems from common carrier or public telephone systems. Early PBX systems used operators to manually connect incoming and outgoing calls. Today, any private telephone system with multiple lines can be called a PBX system.

Traditional PBX systems were only compatible with the Public Switched Telephone Network (PSTN). In the current business telephone market, many PBX systems are compatible with both PSTN and Voice over IP (VoIP) technology. These are sometimes referred to as hybrid systems, and they have the advantage of managing calls for either PSTN or VoIP telephones.

PBX systems can offer many useful features, including auto attendant, auto dial, call hold and forwarding, call waiting, and direct inward dialing (DID). Managing these features on PBX systems can be technically challenging and involve proprietary hardware and software changes, while most VoIP systems have streamlined interfaces that make this task easier.

Implementation:

A PBX system takes all of the phone lines in a business and links it onto one central platform. PBX solutions generally offer technical support for users, but initial implementation and installation can be costly. Switching to a PBX may require purchasing equipment, such as telephones, which impacts costs.

Scale:

Similar to VoIP solutions, PBX systems offer packages for a base number of users. Additional lines and additional users increase costs. Future scaling with PBX may require the purchase of additional equipment.

Features:

PBX systems offer all the functionalities that a business would need—from voicemail to call-waiting and more.

Call quality:

In general, call quality is good with PBX systems and does not present some of the problems that a troublesome internet connection can with VoIP. PBX systems protect sensitive information through secure phone lines and back-up batteries ensure communications in the case of power outages.

Costs:

Depending on the specific needs of a business, a traditional PBX solution can be more costly than VoIP, with variables such as call management, installation, additional lines and features all impacting total costs.

 

VoIP

There are features that VoIP systems offer that are not available in other technologies. Voicemail and fax integration with email are examples of VoIP only features that are becoming standard business features. The ability to receive voicemails and faxes through email can greatly improve productivity and responsiveness for any business. VoIP systems can also include mobile and text messaging capabilities that are not part of the standard PBX feature set.

VoIP systems are more flexible also. Adding lines and users involves making a few changes in a web-based interface, while in a PBX system these may require hardware and software updates. VoIP systems are designed to be scalable and do not require hardware upgrades to add lines or users.

VoIP also has the advantage of decreased calling costs. Because VoIP does not use the PSTN to route calls, the costs of using the traditional telephone network is bypassed. In some cases, such as toll-free services and dedicated long distance, this cost savings is dramatic.

Some businesses have been reluctant to adopt VoIP systems because of concerns over call quality and consistency. With the recent improvements in broadband technology and digital communications, these concerns have effectively been eliminated. Today it is very difficult to distinguish between the quality of a VoIP call and a call made over the traditional telephone network.

When choosing between traditional PBX and VoIP, it is important to determine which features and capabilities are required, along with operating costs over the long term. After a thorough review of these requirements, each business can arrive at the best choice for their situation.

Implementation:

Hardware demands including telephones, tend to be less costly than those required for PBX.

Scale:

VoIP systems are generally designed with scalability in mind, allowing businesses to add lines with relative ease and minimal added equipment costs.

Features:

VoIP offers all the features of traditional phones with added capabilities like call forwarding to the desktop and mobile devices.

Call Quality:

VoIP systems come with some risks including the unpredictable reliability of internet connections that impact voice quality. Call quality is getting better all the time, but it is not always necessarily as secure as a hard phone line.

Costs:

VoIP is generally touted as the cost-saving telecommunications solution that combines incoming, outgoing, local, long-distance calls with internet. Call management with a hosted VoIP solution may add to the final bill, and because business needs can vary widely, it's often difficult to find one price that fits everyone. Business buyers should seek customized quotes and compare these with a PBX equivalent when making the choice for a telecommunications solution.

 

Assess your company's telecommunications needs to see if PBX or VoIP is the right choice. Contact vendors for personalized quotes to meet your feature and scale needs.

Featured Research
  • 15 Traits of a Good Phone System

    While each marketed model has its own host of bells and whistles, when it comes down to it, for you to select the best phone system for your business, focus on little more than these 15 traits! more

  • 2017 Business VoIP Features

    If you’re considering an investment into a new VoIP system (or upgrading an old one), it’s important to understand what features are available and which ones your business will actually need. Especially if you want to keep costs at a minimum. more

  • What To Do When Your VoIP Contract Expires

    Automatically renewing your VoIP contract is a mistake. The VoIP landscape has been changing rapidly, and it pays to review all of your options before committing to another contract. more

  • VoIP Brings Big Benefits to Small Businesses

    If you run a small to midsized business and you're still relying on a traditional phone system, you need to rethink things. VoIP offers most businesses, regardless of the size, huge benefits. For small businesses, it unlocks the opportunity to have an enterprise-level communication system without the traditional expenses. more

  • [Infographic] How UC Can Improve Employee Productivity

    If you’re interested in a straightforward way to improve the productivity of your employees, it's time to consider adopting a Unified Communications (UC) strategy. more