Phone System Review: ShoreTel vs. Mitel

By Ryan Ayers
Updated: September 09, 2011

Choosing the right Unified Communications (UC) solution for your small business can be a complex and research intensive task. Finding a solution that will fit your business’ needs without going overboard in terms of budget can be a tall order for small businesses looking for the best Voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP) phone system or UC solution. Both ShoreTel and Mitel are well regarded providers of VoIP and UC solutions for businesses of all sizes. With pricing that comes in slightly lower than Cisco, Avaya, and several other well known providers, these two telephony vendors are often compared to one another.

ShoreTel vs. Mitel

ShoreTel – ShoreTel is known for both their UC hardware and software, and more recently for the service aspects relating to UC communications. Their full service UC suites encompass voice, data, video, and mobile communication and strive to create the perfect solution for all of your business’ communications needs. Advertising a lower TCO than Cisco and Avaya, ShoreTel is often referred to because of the technical complexity of their systems.

Mitel – Mitel is known for the adaptable and scalable nature of their various UC solutions and the unique “freedom architecture” that they employ. Offering versatility and endless variation when it comes to deployment and implementation on any network, Mitel offers an array of comprehensive communications and collaboration software and equipment. Mitel has a focus on creating an “in-office” environment anywhere and allows users to customize everything from mobile and remote extensions.

The Pros and Cons

ShoreTel – ShoreTel is often favored because of the complexity of its networking and communications solutions. Similar in nature to some of the larger and more expensive business communications solutions, ShoreTel’s systems are also easy to use and feature rich. Scalable from very small business environments up to extremely large companies with thousands of users, ShoreTel solutions can grow with your business. ShoreTel is slightly more expensive than Mitel’s comparable systems, and some complain that many of their solutions operate on Microsoft servers.

ShoreTel Pros:

  • Advanced Hardware and Networking Equipment
  • Extraordinarily Scalable
  • Lower TCO than Many Other Providers
  • Feature Rich
  • Long Hardware Life

ShoreTel Cons:

  • Higher Price Point
  • Microsoft Servers

Mitel – Mitel is touted by many as the cost effective alternative to the comprehensive solutions from larger providers. Their innovative approach to complete UC solutions that allow for extreme mobility and changeability has given them a slightly larger adoption rate than ShoreTel in many areas. Mitel offers its solutions to be deployed as local premise-based, virtualized environment, or cloud hosted solutions and offers a wide range of hardware components to go along with their systems. Many users prefer Mitel handsets and believe that they last longer and outperform competitors. Mitel is sometimes criticized for the slightly less technically complex nature of their systems.

Mitel Pros:

  • Variety of Deployment and Service Options
  • Wider Adoption Rate
  • Superior Hardware
  • Lower Price Point
  • Versatility

Mitel Cons:

  • Less Complex Network


The choice between Mitel and ShoreTel is a matter of organizational preference for most small and medium sized businesses. These two competitors are often compared because of the similarities between their UC offerings and the high levels of service and hardware quality from both. Choosing between the two will likely be a matter of finding the options that best fit your business’ specific needs.
 

Featured Research
  • 7 Ways the Wrong Phone System Can Haunt Your Business

    The wrong phone system could be haunting your business - and we’re talking about problems more serious than ghosts and ghouls. From increased costs to issues with scaling, we’ve identified seven important ways that a less than ideal phone system could be holding you back. You’ll be surprised at how much of a difference this can make to your bottom line too. more

  • Ditch Your Fax Servers

    An in-house fax server gives an IT department centralized management and monitoring over the entire enterprise's faxing. This can help your company track usage and better maintain records for auditing and record keeping. However, there are serious drawbacks that come with utilizing an in-house fax server solution and these range from security to cost-prohibitive pricing. more

  • The IT Manager's Survival Guide

    As an IT manager, maintaining physical fax servers and infrastructure is not a high priority. However, fax capability remains a business need simply because chances are your industry is dependent on its security. What if there was a way to reduce the amount of time spent handling fax complaints and maintaining physical servers? And this way took into account security, cost savings, and freed up your IT resources. Would you be interested? more

  • VoIP: Your New Secret Weapon for a Strong Year End

    As the end of 2017 nears, you may be feeling pressure to make sure you close the year out strong.If you’ve been sitting on the fence regarding VoIP, this may be the perfect time to switch. VoIP options had never been better or more full-featured than they are now, and it may be just the thing your business needs to see a productivity and profitability boost. more

  • Is Your Phone System Stealing Profits?

    Having the wrong phone system can dramatically cut into your profits. Despite this, many businesses just sign up for a plan or platform that seems ‘good enough’. If you haven’t carefully considered your options and the included features, there’s a very good chance that you are leaving money on the table in some way. more