How to Implement a Furlough For Salaried (overtime exempt) and Hourly Employees

Updated: June 16, 2009

To address the ongoing economic downturn, employers are exploring alternatives to reductions in forces, such as wage cuts, shortened weeks, and furloughs (unpaid shutdowns). Following are the general legal concerns which employers should consider before implementing a furlough program:

Wage & Hour Issues:1

Salaried (exempt) employees: Because an exempt employee need not be paid for any workweek in which the employee performs no work, full week, unpaid furloughs are permissible under the Federal Fair Labor Standards Act ("FLSA"), and under most state wage and hour laws. Keep in mind, however, that if a salaried employee performs any work in a workweek, he or she is entitled to their full salary for the week. Therefore, if an employer implements week-long furloughs the employer will also need to institute and distribute a policy prohibiting the furloughed employees from performing any work during the furlough. To the extent some minimal amount of work is performed during a furlough week (e.g., returning a phone message or answering an email), an employer could also argue that the work is de minimis, and therefore not compensable.

Partial-week furloughs (e.g., a four-day workweek schedule at 20% reduction in pay; or mandatory days off without pay), are not without risk under the wage and hour laws, but there are some creative solutions that have passed legal muster under wage and hour laws when certain criteria have been met.

  • For example, on the issue of shortened workweeks with a concomitant reduction in pay, the U.S. Department of Labor ("DOL") has taken the position that such reductions in salary are permissible and will not defeat the exemption, provided that the reduction in salary (1) is bona fide and not intended to circumvent the salary basis test; (2) does not bring the salary to below the minimum threshold; (3) is prospective; and (4) is not done so frequently that the salary becomes a "sham" for hourly wages.

According to various DOL Opinion Letters, reducing salary once or twice each year does not violate the salary basis test.2 In addition, two cases can be interpreted to support more frequent reductions in salary, up to four or five times per year.3 However, there is one federal case that has held that an employer's decision to reduce salary and hours resulted in the loss of the employees' exempt status.4

Relying on the DOL opinion letters and the 10th Circuit's 2005 Wal-Mart decision, an Illinois Appellate court recently applied that same analysis in a case involving exempt employees who were required to take time off without pay during certain holiday weeks.5 There, the court held that forced time off without pay during holiday weeks did not destroy the subject employees' exempt status because the mandatory unpaid time off was based on a bona fide business need; was a prospective reduction in pay rather than a prohibited deduction in pay, and was only required infrequently.

Hourly (non-exempt) Employees: To the extent an employer considers requiring non-exempt employees to take furloughs, off-the-clock work could be an issue here as with exempt employees. As mentioned above, however, an employer could address that issue by communicating to furloughed employees that they are not permitted to perform any work during the furlough.

EEO Issues: Just like in a RIF situation, an employer could potentially face claims of discrimination under disparate impact and/or disparate treatment theories if some proportion of employees selected for the furlough program fall within a category protected by the various anti-discrimination laws. Therefore, it makes sense for employers to take a look at the demographic makeup of the selected employees before instituting the program.

Contractual and/or Benefit Plan Issues: Employers also review employee contracts, handbooks and benefit plan documents to check for any contractual obligations that could be compromised by a furlough program. In addition, to the extent that benefit plans and/or handbooks condition certain benefits on the number of hours an employee works in a given week, such that a furlough program could result in the loss of healthcare coverage, the program could also trigger COBRA obligations.

1 See 29 C.F.R. §§ 541.602, 541.603; 820 ILCS 105/4a(2)(E).

2 See Wage and Hour Opinion Letter dated 11/13/70, 1970 WL 26462 (salary reduction 2 times per year is OK); Wage and Hour Opinion Letter dated 03/04/97, 1997 WL 998010 (salary reduction once per year is OK); Wage and Hour Opinion Letter dated 02/23/98, 1998 WL 852696 (salary reduction once per year is OK); see also Archeluta v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., 2008 WL 4457699 (10th Cir. 2008) (salary reduction two times per year is OK).

3 See e.g., Caperci v. Rite Aid Corp., 43 F.Supp.2d 83, n.14 (D. Mass. 1999) (reducing pay on a "handful of occasions" is okay); In re Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., 395 F.3d 1777 (10th Cir. 2005) (pay reductions due to seasonal decreases in sales during the summer months is okay).

4 See Dingwall v. Friedman, 3 F.Supp.2d 215 (S.D.N.Y. 1998). However, that case did not address the DOL Opinion Letters at all, and was criticized by the 10th Circuit in the Wal-Mart case.

5 See Robinson v. Tellabs, slip op., Case No. 02 CH 2860 (1st Dist. April 27, 2009).

Featured Research
  • 5 Common Pain Points CRM Solutions Eliminate

    With a good CRM solution, you can create a record of every interaction between your company and the customer, allowing you to see a 360-degree view of the customer. more

  • 9 Must-Have Contact Center Features

    In today’s highly communicative world, one unhappy customer can have a devastating effect on a company’s reputation. Fortunately, technological innovations address many of the standard customer service challenges. more

  • Top 15 Questions to Ask When Selecting a VoIP Provider

    With so many financial and functional advantages offered by VoIP technology, making the transition is increasingly mandatory. Selecting VoIP services for business is one of the most critical—and difficult—IT decisions that your company will face. Clarify your business needs and simplify the decision-making process with these top 15 questions. more

  • The Advantages of Unified Communications

    How can you get the most out of a Unified Communications solution? Let us keep you one step ahead of the game, giving you the knowledge it takes to make an informed UC purchasing decision! more

  • Best Practices for an Integrated Sales Funnel

    While some people use the terms CRM and MAP interchangeably, they actually refer to two distinct software categories. But much like peanut butter and jelly, CRM and MAP work better together. Learning more about these two types of software and how they can be integrated is critical for developing a robust sales funnel that doesn’t leak. more