The Most Frivolous Lawsuits Thrown At Apple

Updated: May 23, 2011

Apple Inc. -- the multinational electronics and software giant responsible for fueling our obsessions with iPods, iPads, and iPhones -- has had a lot of lawsuits thrown at it. (With a reported Q1 2011 revenue of $26.74 billion, and a projected Q2 of $22 billion, is it any wonder that every other person with a grudge wants money from them?) Here's a look at some of the most frivolous lawsuits thrown at Apple--in history:

iPhone Battery Life

In 2007, a customer filed a class-action suit against Apple for iPhone's lack of a user-replaceable battery. Jose Trujillo claimed in his suit that: "Unknown to the plaintiff, and undisclosed to the public, the iPhone is a sealed unit with its battery soldered on the inside of the device so that it cannot be changed by the owner." However, Apple has always made it clear that the iPhone lacks a replaceable battery; moreover, its design makes it so that the battery will retain 80% capacity even after 400 charging/discharging cycles.

iPod Hearing Loss

In 2006, a Louisiana man filed a complaint against Apple (the actual suit was filed in San Jose, California) charging that "the iPod music player can produce sounds up to 115 decibels even though some studies suggest that listening to music at that level for 28 seconds a day can cause damage over time." The suit also states that "Millions of consumers have had their hearing put at risk by Apple's conduct." The requests? A software upgrade, limiting the iPod's output to 100 decibels, and a share of the iPod's profits." The case was ultimately dismissed in 2009 -- the court ruled that the iPod's potential for causing hearing loss did not "represent a reasonable cause of action," since iPods can also be used in a way that doesn't cause hearing loss.

Overheating iPad

iPads are just like books, but aren't actually books. Right? Well, one 2010 lawsuit claims that Apple's marketing materials are false, since, contrary to Apple's claim that "Reading on iPad is just like reading a book," using the iPad is not "just like reading a book" at all since books do not close when the reader is enjoying them in the sunlight or in other environments." The three plaintiffs claim that the iPad "does not live up to reasonable consumer's expectations created by Apple insofar as the iPad overheats so quickly under common weather conditions." In February 2011, a federal judge tossed that lawsuit, writing that the "allegations were insufficient."

Bad Reception

In July 2010, the so-called iPhone 4 "death grip" caused two Maryland residents, Kevin McCaffrey and Linda Wrinn, to file a class-action lawsuit against Apple, claiming "negligence, fraud, and deceptive trade practices." The suit claimed that both plaintiffs began to "experience significantly reduced reception and performance when handling the phones." The court claimed that the plaintiffs could not return their phones without incurring a 10% re-stocking fee. The two are currently suing for damages "and other remedies."

iPod Nano Scratches

In 2005, iPod consumer Jason Tomczak filed a class-action suit against Apple for ignoring "obvious defects" with the iPod nano. The lead attorney, Steve Berman, wrote that "We intend to prove that in an effort to rush the iPod nano to the market, Apple ignored defects in the design and later tried to cover up negative responses received from consumers…We seek to recover money lost in purchasing this product as well as the $25 fee Apple has chosen to impose on those who have returned their product after it became unusable." The press release described the nano's defects, writing that "In designing the nano, Apple reconstructed the housing into a seamless front where the screen and controls reside directly under a much less durable film of resin allowing irreparable damage to occur." In 2006, Tomczak balked, saying he never wanted anything to do with the case, claiming that he only spoke to lawyers to give them background information. In 2009, Apple agreed to pay a $22.5 million settlement -- amounting to refunds of about $15-$25 per person.

Featured Research
  • 2017 Business Intelligence Trends

    It's long been thought that business intelligence (BI) could only be utilized by highly trained analysts and was therefore unattainable for most businesses. However, advancements in BI have made it so that everyone can utilize BI solutions to help shape business decisions and drive companies bottom lines. more

  • Your Phone System and Your Bottom Line

    Businesses have been using phones to drive increases to their bottom lines for almost a century now. Telephony, much like the rest of the business world, has seen drastic changes with the increase in technological advancement. Voice Over Internet Protocol (VoIP), has enabled companies to connect with consumers at levels that have been seen as unheard of before. And trust us when we say this, it is doing wonders for the bottom line. more

  • How to Scale a Contact Center in 2017

    Are you on the fence about scaling your contact center and not sure how or whether or not now is the time? Studies have shown that 93% of executives expect that contact volume will remain constant or increase within the next two years. This means that now more than ever is the time to begin scaling and we are here to help. more

  • Making the Case for a New CRM

    Did you know that having an outdated CRM is just as bad as not having one at all? Do you find yourself working even just a little too hard to make your current CRM work to maintain your contacts and relationships? While it is increasingly more difficult to reduce customer churn, modern CRM tools are much more powerful and provide much more opportunity to develop stronger relationships with your clients that can provide more stability and revenue to your company and bottom line. more

  • 2017 Phone Systems Checklist

    As you are well aware, we are living in an age of extreme technological growth. With this, an understatement might be that phone systems have changed a bit over the last decade. If you are in the market for a new phone system, it is absolutely essential for you to have knowledge of this vast sector and just what exactly you need in order to have your business succeed. more